After reading this article in the May issue of Saveur, I found myself with both a fascination and an appetite for eel. Our fish vendor, Blue Moon, had recently returned to the greenmarket and the very next Saturday I made a point of buying some smoked eel.
My first instinct after reading the article was to make an eel dish similar to what I’ve eaten in Japanese restaurants, something to top with a sweet sauce and serve with rice. But once I had some smoked eel in my hands (this stuff has a pungent smokey scent that makes you think of bacon, not sushi) I was on a wild internet goose chase for a recipe or some inspiration for a dish I might prepare. After much digging, I discovered a few British recipes suggesting the smoked eel be paired with potato pancakes and sour cream, I decided to take a shot a pairing the eel with some pierogies (from the “Saugerties pierogi lady”, recently gifted to me by the wonderful Ray Bradley) and creme fraiche with fresh grated horseradish.
You should have seen Brad’s face when I told him what we’d be eating for dinner – I admit it sounded like an odd combo – and I thought he’d never even try it after he watched me separate the eel flesh from the spine. But he couldn’t resist when the plates with pierogies came out, and the eel? It was out of this world. The smokey flavor was an awesome complement to the creamy potato pierogi filling and the horseradish, the perfect spicy accent to the whole dish (after all, you eat your eel sushi with wasabi, don’t you?). Since then we’ve simplified and eat the smoked eel and horseradish cream on toasts.

You’re welcome internets, here is an approachable (and delicious) recipe for smoked eel.
Smoked Eel and Chives with Horseradish Creme on Toast
- ½ pound smoked eel, skin and spine removed, shredded or finely chopped
- handful of chives, chopped
- 1 lemon, zest and juice
- A few tablespoons creme fraiche
- grated fresh horseradish*
- toasts for serving
Combine eel, chives, lemon zest and juice. Allow to rest, salt to taste before serving. You might be tempted to add oil to this, but remember the eel is a oily fish – it won’t be dry.
Mix creme fraiche (you could also use sour cream) with finely grated (I use my microplane) fresh horseradish – you can determine the ratio depending on how much of the horseradish spiciness you prefer.
Make some toasts from a good baguette.
Top the toasts with a light “schmear” of the horseradish cream and pile on a bit of the smoked eel. Serve and watch your guests become ravenous for more.
*As fresh horseradish becomes unavailable this summer, I’ll try using prepared instead. 10 points for other ideas or suggestions.